Once a Panther, Always a Panther
| Name | Class | University/Professional |
|---|---|---|
| Adam Euler | 2020 | University of Evansville (committed) |
Aaron Massie | 2020 | Miami of Ohio (committed) |
Nolan Cook | 2019 | University of Southern Indiana |
| Cameron Frey | 2019 | University of Southern Indiana |
| Logan Maynard | 2019 | Vincennes University |
Gehrig Tenhumberg | 2019 | Vincennes University |
| Elijah Dunham | 2017 | Indiana University |
Luke Euler | 2017 | University of Southern Indiana |
| Aaron Euler | 2016 | University of Southern Indiana |
| Trevor Ricker | 2016 | University of Southern Indiana |
| Houston Huff | 2015 | University of Southern Indiana |
| Kenny Hansen III | 2014 | University of Illinois at Springfield |
| Austin Myers | 2014 | Vincennes University |
| Wes Brown | 2013 | Wabash College |
| Logan Hopple | 2013 | Brescia University |
| Drew Johnston | 2013 | Vincennes University |
| Lance Myers | 2012 | Vincennes University / Ashland University |
| Daniel Sander | 2012 | Vincennes University / Purdue University |
| Hamilton Carr | 2011 | University of Southern Indiana |
| Jarret Young | 2011 | Olney Central / IU Southeast |
| Erik Bryant | 2010 | Wabash College |
| Craig Austin | 2008 | University of Southern Indiana |
| Chris Deig | 2008 | Wabash College |
| Travis McClarney | 2007 | Heidelberg University |
| Josh Schultze | 2007 | University of Southern Indiana |
| Daniel Schweikhart | 2007 | University of Southern Indiana |
| Jared DeLong | 2006 | Wabash Valley / Austin Peay |
| Geoff Oxley | 2006 | Boston College |
| Zach Barrett | 2004 | Olney Central / Middle Tennessee |
| Mark Kirkman | 2004 | St. Oakland City University |
| Jay Buente | 2002 | Purdue University / Florida Marlins |
| Andy Cook | 1997 | University of Southern Indiana |
| Jeremy Cook | 1995 | University of Southern Indiana |
Jay Sparks | 1995 | University of Southern Indiana |
| Roger Goedde | 1994 | Pittsburgh Pirates |
| Korey Lamb | 1992 | University of Southern Indiana |
| Mike Fetscher | 1991 | University of Southern Indiana |
| Kyle Kassel | 1989 | University of Southern Indiana |
| Todd DeWeese | 1986 | University of Southern Indiana University of Southern Indiana |
| Jeff Thompson | 1986 | University of Southern Indiana |